After 50 days on the market and a price cut, the owner of a three-bedroom home in Orlando’s Avalon Park still had no offers. True North Managed reports that she withdrew the listing and signed a lease at $2,395 a month. She based her asking rent on what comparable nearby homes had actually leased for. Those deals ranged from $2,300 to $2,450, below the asking rents she saw on homes that were still available. truenorthmanaged.com
The rent covered the bills. The margin was thin.
True North projected about $456 a month left after the mortgage payment, property taxes, landlord insurance, and HOA dues. That figure fell slightly below break-even once the owner budgeted for vacancy and maintenance. The owner was self-managing, and the projection depended in part on a 3% mortgage she already had. An owner with a higher payment or a management fee could get a very different result from the same rent.
Three numbers to compare
The case comes down to three numbers. Start with what you would net from taking a realistic offer today. Then calculate what it costs to keep the house empty each month. Finally, estimate what you would keep by renting it after insurance, taxes, dues, repairs, vacancy, and any management fees. If you still plan to sell, factor in the cost of preparing the house for sale again and whether the lease end date fits your selling timeline.

Paul’s Take
A tenant can help cover the cost of waiting, but the sale price you’ll get next year is still an unknown. Run the comparison using today’s realistic sale price as the price you’d get after the lease. If renting still makes sense after you budget for repairs and vacancy, the decision can stand on its own. If the numbers only work when the house sells for more later, you’re counting on a price recovery.
This article uses True North Managed’s November 13 Avalon Park case study. The newsletter landing page was inaccessible.