Part 4 of 4 — What Happens When You Sell?
The first-year deduction lowers your tax basis. A lower basis can produce a larger taxable gain when you sell. That gain depends on how much you receive for the building, land and separately depreciated assets. The mortgage payoff determines how much cash you take home. It doesn’t determine the taxable gain. IRS Publication 544
Assume a sale after five years for $470,000, with selling costs of 6%. Assign $20,000 of the gross price to fully depreciated Section 1245 assets and $450,000 to the building and land, using supportable market values in an actual sale. Allocate selling costs proportionately in this model. Assume $36,000 of cumulative straight-line building depreciation. That rounded amount is an exit-model input. In practice, the building classification, recovery period and placed-in-service and sale dates control the calculation.
| Sale calculation | Section 1245 assets | Building and land | Total |
| Gross sale proceeds | $20,000 | $450,000 | $470,000 |
| Allocated selling costs | −$1,200 | −$27,000 | −$28,200 |
| Net proceeds before debt | $18,800 | $423,000 | $441,800 |
| Adjusted tax basis | $0 | $339,000 | $339,000 |
| Taxable gain | $18,800 | $84,000 | $102,800 |
| Federal tax illustration | Gain | Assumed rate | Estimated tax |
| Ordinary income from Section 1245 recapture | $18,800 | 24% | $4,512 |
| Unrecaptured Section 1250 gain tied to building depreciation | $36,000 | 25% | $9,000 |
| Remaining gain, assuming long-term capital gains treatment | $48,000 | 15% | $7,200 |
| Estimated federal tax on the sale | $102,800 | | $20,712 |
The 25% rate is a federal maximum for unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. The illustration assumes the stated rates apply and excludes any net investment income tax, Section 1231 lookback adjustment and effect of any suspended passive losses. A qualifying fully taxable sale of an entire passive activity to an unrelated buyer can generally release suspended passive losses. IRS Publication 544 · IRS capital gains rate guidance · IRS Publication 925
After 60 mortgage payments, the modeled loan balance is about $296,515. Subtract the loan payoff and estimated sale tax from $441,800 in net proceeds and the investor walks away with about $124,573 at closing after allowing for those taxes. That’s about $5,927 below the original $130,500 cash invested. The closing figure excludes five years of operating cash flows and the tax effects during ownership. The $20,712 sale tax includes tax on appreciation and building depreciation as well as bonus-related recapture. Only $4,512 in this illustration is specifically tied to the fully expensed Section 1245 assets.

Paul’s Take
At this price, a few soft booking weeks or the need for a manager can erase the operating profit. The tax break can have real value, especially when you can use it early and hold the property for years. I’d want to see the projected cash flow after paying for my time and the after-tax proceeds at the price I can reasonably expect to sell for. On these assumptions, I’d keep looking.